As someone who’s lived in Nutley my whole life, I’ve seen Pizzerias come and go, and have continued to enjoy the ones that are still here today.
Basically, pizza and Nutley are synonymous.
When it comes to the food scene in Nutley, you can’t NOT talk about pizza.
Everyone’s taste buds are different, but I’m going to go over the best pizza places in Nutley that you’re bound to like no matter who you are.
Ralph’s Pizzeria – Top Of The List
See my full Ralphs review here!
Ralph’s Pizzeria Information
Address: 564 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110
Phone number: (973) 235-1130
Website: Ralph’s Pizzeria
Hours:
- Monday: 4:00 PM – 10:00 PM
- Tuesday to Sunday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM
Delivery Information
It’s important to note that Ralph’s Pizzeria does not offer delivery services. So, if you’re craving their delicious pizza, you’ll have to swing by their location for pick-up.
Number one, from a tastiness and longevity standpoint, is Ralphs.
Even if you’re not from Nutley, there’s a good chance you’ve heard of them.
Afterall, they’ve received one of the highest ratings on barstool which was an 8.9.
What Is Ralph’s Pizza Known For?
When it comes to pizza, Ralphs is known for their thin and crispy crust. They have the balance of sauce and cheese just right as well.
They have a way of creating a taste that isn’t quite like any other pizza.
Another slice I’ll get every once in a while is their buffalo chicken slice, but all in all I usually just get their plain pie.
What Do Customers Have To Say About Ralphs?
I know I like Ralphs, but I also want to incorporate how other people feel about Ralphs as well. After looking through as many reviews as I can.Here are the main takeaways.
- Excellent taste and flavor of the pizzas.
- Thin, crispy crust that holds up well under the toppings.
- Perfect balance of sauce and cheese on the pizzas.
- Variety of pizza options, including unique choices like the Buffalo Chicken pizza and the Whole Wheat pizza.
- The pizzas are well done with little to no flop.
- Fresh ingredients used in the pizzas.
- The pizzeria holds a lot of nostalgia and fond memories for long-time customers.
- Good customer service and a cozy, welcoming ambiance.
- Convenient opening hours, accommodating both early and late pizza cravings.
- No delivery service; pick-up only.
Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza
Address: 170 Chestnut St, Nutley, NJ 07110
Phone: (973) 320-2339
Hours:
- Wednesday: 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM
- Thursday: 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM
- Friday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM
- Saturday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM
- Sunday: 1:00 PM – 7:00 PM
- Monday and Tuesday: Closed
About Emilios Wood Fire Pizza
Before we get started, we already did a full review of Emilios, which you can see here!
Emilios Wood fire Pizza is known for its authentic Neapolitan style Pizza, which is cooked in a real wood fire oven.
It’s one of those places that you have to go there to eat, just to experience the freshness of the ingredients.
Just like Ralphs, delivery isn’t available, which is probably for the best being woodfired pizza is best straight out of the oven.
What Do Customers Have To Say About Emilios
- Customers love the freshness and quality of the pizzas.
- The homemade pesto and the Hot Honey pizza are particularly popular.
- The crust is described as exceptional.
- Customers appreciate the friendly staff and the cozy, clean environment.
- The owner is often mentioned for his friendliness and passion for Italian pizza.
- The Cold Antipasto is recommended as a starter, described as excellent and generous in portion.
- The restaurant is small and cozy, with the wood burning oven as the main attraction.It’s a family-owned business, which adds to the charm and authenticity.
Cucina 355
Address: 355 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110
Phone: (973) 798-4500
Hours:
- Monday to Thursday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Friday and Saturday: 11:00 AM – 12:00 PM
- Sunday: 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM
What Is Cucina 355 Known For?
Cucina is one of my favorites. I love their pepperoni pie.
However, they are also known for a variation of different pies including their Grandma pie and their Penne vodka pizza.
Delivery Information
Cucina 355 offers both takeout and delivery services, making it a convenient choice for those who want to enjoy their food at home.
Takeaways From Reviews
- Customers appreciate the diverse and creative menu, which caters to a variety of dietary preferences, including gluten-free and dairy-free options.
- The ambiance of the restaurant is often praised, with customers noting the split between a casual dining area and a more formal dining section.
- The food is consistently described as delicious, with particular praise for the eggplant parmigiana, chicken marsala, and penne with vodka sauce.
- The service is generally described as excellent, with friendly and attentive staff.
Amore Pizza by Jack Calandra
Information
- Address: 371 Centre St, Nutley, NJ 07110
- Hours: Monday to Saturday: 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Sunday: Closed
- Known for: Thin crust pizza, Italian dishes
- Delivery: Yes, via delivery apps
About Amore Pizza By Jack Calandra
Amore arrived in Nutley just a couple years ago. They took over the spot that housed soup/ice hut, ritas, and Gencarelli’s pizza. All known spots in Nutley over the years (I still remember the soup hut bread).
Amores is owned by Jack Calandra, as the name of the business states. They have roots in Newark, Bloomfield, and Montclair.
I’ve tried their thinny skinny pie, plain cheese pie, and the Nutley Tomato pizza, all of which were very good.
What Customers Have To Say About Amore Pizza By Jack Calandra
- Customers love the thin crust pizza, particularly the “thinny skinny” and grandma pie.
- The sauce is often praised for its flavor.
- Some customers feel the pizza could use more cheese.
- The staff is described as friendly and the location is convenient with ample parking.
- Some customers feel the prices are a bit high, especially when ordering through delivery apps.
- The pizza is often compared favorably to other popular pizzerias in the area.
Queen Margherita Trattoria
- Address: 246 Washington Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110
- Phone: (973) 662-0007
- Hours: Open 11:30 AM – 2:30 PM, Reopens 4:30 PM – 10:00 PM
- Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free Options
About Queen Margherita Trattoria
Queen Margherita is known for its dining experience and is way more than just a pizza place. However, the pizza is what we’ll focus on.
When it comes to pizza they are known for their artisanal style.
If you’re looking for pizza and a night out. Queen Margherita is a perfect place to bring your family.
Customer Review Takeaways
- Customers appreciate the friendly and attentive service.
- The food, particularly the stuffed flounder, veal cacciatore, and Margherita pizza, receives high praise.
- The restaurant is noted for its family atmosphere.
- Some customers have mentioned the restaurant’s singing owner and his daughter, adding a unique touch to the dining experience.
- A few customers have mentioned that the restaurant can be busy, and reservations are recommended.
- Some customers have mentioned that the restaurant could use a facelift, indicating that the decor may be a bit dated.
- The restaurant’s lunch special is highly recommended by some customers for its value.
Conclusion
Nutley is full of great pizza places. Even the places that aren’t rated the best are still probably better than most towns’ pizza.
I hope this list helped you narrow down which places in Nutley you want to try.
If you have any recommendations for pizza, leave them down below.
